Skip to main content
Research/Evaluation Report

Vacancy Referrals, Job Search, and the Duration of Unemployment: A Randomized Experiment

About

Explores how job referrals and the "threat" of increased monitoring affects the probability of unemployed job seekers to apply for vacant positions and the duration of employment within that position.
"The referral of unemployed job seekers to job vacancies is [a] key instrument whereby the public employment service (PES) attempts to facilitate the matching between job seekers and vacancies. This instrument is also used as a device to monitor job search[es], thereby reducing the moral hazard problems in unemployment insurance. A job seeker who fails to apply for a job that he is referred to runs a risk of being sanctioned, i.e., being exposed to a benefit withdrawal or a benefit reduction. However, a credible threat of a benefit sanction requires that PES gathers and uses information on whether referrals lead to actual job applications....[This] study focuses on vacancy referrals in Sweden, a country well known for its ambitious active labor market policies. The vacancy referral process is a key ingredient of these policies....[This study] examine[s] how the vacancy referral process works and focus[es] on three main questions:  

[1] Do referrals lead to actual job applications? [2] Does a “threat” of increased monitoring affect the probability of searching for a job that a worker is referred to? [3] How does this threat affect the duration of unemployment?

To answer these questions, we have undertaken a randomized experiment based on a sample of vacancy referrals during the fall of 2007. Surveys to employers were used to get information about how often referrals lead to job applications. Some unemployed job seekers – the “treatment groups” – were alerted (via letters from PES) to an increased risk of being monitored, i.e., an increased probability that their referral would be checked with the employer" (p.1-2). (Abstractor: Author and Website Staff)

Major Findings and Recommendations

The Effect of Referrals: - "Results of the survey revealed that "over 30 percent of referrals did not result in job applications. This number may perhaps appear to be on the high side, but the lack of previous studies cautions against strong priors about what is reasonable or not. (p.12) The Threat of Intensified Monitoring: - "The impact of information on search behavior and the “threat” of a referral follow-up...[lead to an] application rate 4 percentage points higher in treatment group, However, the difference is only marginally significant. - Those who are young or have short previous unemployment spells appear highly responsive. - Older individuals and those with experiences of long spells of unemployment have presumably learned that the risk of benefit sanction is very low, despite strict formal rules, and adjusted their behavior accordingly." (p.13) The Impact on Unemployment Duration: - "There is no evidence that advance warning about intensified follow-ups of referrals has any positive (or negative) impact on unemployment duration" (p.17). (Abstractor: Author and Website Staff)

Materials

Comments

Content Details

Methodology:

Topics:

Target Populations:

Programs:

Geographic Locations:

Industry Sectors:

  • Last Updated:
  • Created:
  • Resource Publication Date: 2009
  • Author(s): Engström, Per; Hesselius, Patrik; Holmlund, Bertil
  • Organizational Author(s): The Institute for the Study of Labor and Uppsala University
  • Funding Source: Institute for the Study of Labor
  • Resource Availability: Publicly available
  • Posted by:
  • Posted in: Workforce System Strategies

Error

An error has occurred. The details of this error have been forwarded to our technical team. If you continue to experience issues, please contact our support team at support@workforcegps.org.

Event has ended