Strategies to Productively Reincorporate the Formerly-Incarcerated into Communities
About
Presents a literature review of studies conducted in 2010 or later that focus on reentry strategies and outcomes—including recidivism, employment, and educational attainment of individuals exiting the criminal justice system in the U.S. and similar countries.
“Studies must also consider impacts on those already involved in the criminal justice system – that is, this review does not include studies focused on prevention of initial criminal justice contact...” (p.11).
“A primary goal of this review was to identify strategies that could productively reincorporate formerly-incarcerated black and Latino youth into their communities. Given their disproportionate representation in the U.S. criminal justice system, young men of color are the most likely to benefit from programs that improve prisoner reentry outcomes. However, it would be useful to know if some programs are more successful at reducing racial disparities than others. With few exceptions, the existing evidence base is…too thin to determine programs’ relative impacts across subgroups of interest. At this point, there is more evidence pointing to differential effects by age than by race. Throughout the review, [the author discusses] the composition of study samples, so that readers can get a sense of the contexts in which particular effects were found” (p.12).
“The existing studies span a variety of topics that signal the array of challenges faced by the criminal-justice-involved population, and the consequent diversity of programs designed to help this group. These topics include: employment, housing, mental health treatment, substance abuse treatment, multi-faceted interventions that address many needs at once, diversion from incarceration, changing intensity of community supervision, and expanding DNA databases” (p. 3-4).
(Abstractor: Author and Website Staff)
Full publication title: Strategies to Productively Reincorporate the Formerly-Incarcerated into Communities: A Review of the Literature
Major Findings and Recommendations
Findings on employment include:
- “Many programs focus on increasing employment for people with criminal records, with the hope that access to a steady job will prevent reoffending. This topic has been studied more than others, and the research results are mixed” (p.4).
Findings on housing include:
- “There is currently very little evidence on the effects of housing-focused strategies” (p.5).
Findings on mental health treatment include:
- “A growing body of evidence supports CBT [cognitive behavioral therapy] as a cost-effective intervention, though the evidence on MST [multisystemic therapy] is more mixed and may be context-dependent. In both cases, it is unclear how much effectiveness will fall if programs are scaled up to serve more people: if they require highly-trained psychologists to conduct the sessions, the scalability will be limited” (p.6).
Findings on substance abuse treatment include:
- “A large share of jail and prison inmates have histories of substance abuse, which suggests that helping this population manage addictions may reduce criminal activity. Unfortunately, there is currently limited evidence on the effectiveness of programs with this goal” (p.6).
- “While the research discussed above provides…guidance to policy-makers and practitioners looking to improve reentry outcomes, there is still a great deal [unknown]…” (p.41).
- “The programs that seem most promising are court-issued rehabilitation certificates, cognitive behavioral therapy, diversion from short incarceration spells, reducing intensity of community supervision, and expanding DNA databases” (p.41).
- “Evidence is mixed regarding the effectiveness of multisystemic therapy and HOPE” (p.41).
- The HOPE program applies “swift, certain, and fair sanctions to individuals who are court-ordered to remain sober” (p.6).
- “Evidence is decidedly negative on the effectiveness of transitional jobs programs, Ban the Box [policies], and wrap-around services.” (p.41).
- “There are many interventions that have been studied but about which there is still too little evidence to conclude effectiveness. These include Individual Placement and Support, employer education about criminal records, emergency financial assistance for housing, medication-assisted treatment for addiction, Therapeutic Communities, incentivizing and facilitating engagement in substance abuse treatment, and focused deterrence” (p.41).
(Author: Abstractor and Website Staff)
Materials
Comments
Content Details
Methodology:
Topics:
Target Populations:
Programs:
Geographic Locations:
Industry Sectors:
- Last Updated:
- Created:
- Resource Publication Date: 2018
- Author(s): Doleac, Jennifer L.
- Organizational Author(s): Texas A&M University and IZA Institute of Labor Economics
- Resource Availability: Publicly available
- Posted by: Damon Jones
- Posted in: Workforce System Strategies