Skip to main content
Research/Evaluation Report

Pasco Hernando Workforce Board Workforce Innovation Fund Grant Evaluation

About

Pasco-Hernando Workforce Board (PHWB), a Workforce Innovation Fund (WIF) recipient, employed its grant resources to expand remotely available services in Pasco and Hernando counties in Florida. The goal of the project was to reach the large, poorly served geographic service area more effectively by providing expanded phone-based and online customer services. This would help overcome limited public transportation options that restrict in-person access to American Job Centers.

The PHWB grant allowed for an expansion of its Employment Support Center (ESC) call center to improve phone-based outreach and to provide resources and employment-related assistance over the phone. Through the ESC, PHWB staff provided job referrals, follow-ups to employment services, and responses to questions. PHWB also developed a variety of web-accessible, self-directed, and interactive informational videos on topics related to job search strategies and expanded its social media presence to increase customer knowledge about the services available through the area's American Job Centers.

The evaluation of the PHWB grant included an implementation assessment and outcomes and cost evaluation study. To examine the implementation, the researchers examined participant characteristics, the innovation (the ESC and other remote service delivery methods), and how well the innovation was implemented. The outcome study examined whether innovation participants had improved outcomes compare to a control group as a result of their participation, which elements of the innovation were most successful, and whether the innovation was an effective use of programmatic spending.

There were three innovation elements in the funded activities. First, social media was used to target customers with job-seeking information to expedite their process. Second, the employment support center was expanded to increases the available staff and services offered, including live chat and Netop. Netop is a software program to enable staff to remotely access a customer’s computer to offer real-time assistance. Third, self-directed, interactive informational video modules were developed and made available online.

There were six research questions the study sought to answer:

  1. Who are the participants, and what are their characteristics?
  2. What is the innovation?
  3. How well is the innovation implemented?
  4. Dos the innovation improve participant outcomes when compared to outcomes for non-participants?
  5. What innovation elements contribute to improved outcomes?
  6. How much does the innovation(s) cost?

Major Findings and Recommendations

The study highlighted the following findings:

  • The use of remote services increased program staff’s capacity to deliver services, collect accurate data, and follow-up on customer’s outcomes. The study also found that participants who engaged in particular remote services (such as recruitment events, job fairs, online orientation, resume completion, training search, and/or follow-up from ESC workers) were more likely to become employed than job-seekers that engaged in traditional in-person services, based on a quasi-experimental design. Engaging in career guidance, assistance with job search, or referrals to WIOA services did not increase employment levels.
  • Staff-assisted customers who received job-search or an in-person orientation were more likely to find employment than self-assisted participants. Staff assisted services that were not associated with obtaining employment included “intensive” services provided by staff, a referral to another program, and staff-assisted labor market research.
  • Self-assisted customers were 83 percent more likely to obtain employment than individuals who engaged in no services.
  • The implementation study found that self-assisted customers reported that it was beneficial to receive information on workforce services without physically appearing at an office. However, those who had less computer literacy also expressed more frustration with remote services than other customers.
  • Staff reported that, because some customers used the ESC instead of seeking in-person office staff, staff had a greater capacity to serve customers who did come to the office. Staff also noted that the ESC allowed staff to more easily follow up with customers via phone regarding their job search and to more easily maintain accurate information on whether job referrals resulted in employment.
  • Self-assisted Customers did not consistently utilize social media tools that were developed, and results from the customer survey suggest these tools did not improve customers’ engagement in employment-related services.

Recommendations Include:

  1. Provide additional resources or training to build customers' computer literacy;
  2. Make web sites more user friendly and continue to offer in-person services for customers that do not have readily available computer or Internet access; and
  3. Since social media tools did not resonate with some customers, ensure that in-person and phone services are available.

Materials

Comments

Content Details

Methodology:

Topics:

Target Populations:

Programs:

Geographic Locations:

Industry Sectors:

  • Last Updated:
  • Created:
  • Resource Publication Date: 2015
  • Author(s): George MacDonald, Jennifer Hunsecker, Rginald Lee, Roger Villamar, Connie Walker-Egea
  • Funding Source: U.S. Department of Labor, Employment and Training Administration
  • Resource Availability: Publicly available
  • Posted by: Placido Gomez
  • Posted in: Workforce System Strategies

Error

An error has occurred. The details of this error have been forwarded to our technical team. If you continue to experience issues, please contact our support team at support@workforcegps.org.

Event has ended