Skip to main content
Research/Evaluation Report

What Works During Economic Recessions and Recoveries? Evidence from the Pathways Clearinghouse

About

Evidence on programs that have improved employment/earnings for people with low incomes during past recessions and recoveries can help policymakers and practitioners target their resources as they seek to improve employment in the wake of the pandemic and beyond. To support these decision-makers, the researchers used research literature to inform a meta-analysis of data from the Pathways Clearinghouse to understand the interventions and types of services with the strongest evidence of success.

This overview provides a summary of findings on interventions to improve outcomes during different economic conditions. The researchers assessed the following questions:

  1. Do interventions designed to improve employment outcomes for people with low incomes show evidence of effectiveness during recessions and recoveries?
  2. What specific types of interventions work to improve employment?
  3. How should providers consider altering operations in response to economic conditions?

For this analysis, the researchers examined the effects of interventions for people with low incomes on employment, earnings, long-term public benefit receipt, and education and training outcomes. In this analysis, they did not examine effects on short-term benefit receipt—one of the outcomes the Pathways Clearinghouse typically examines because immediately reducing public benefit receipt might not be desirable in all economic conditions. They defined recessions as periods of rising unemployment (years in which the national unemployment rate grew by 0.5 percentage points or more), recoveries as periods of declining unemployment (years in which the national unemployment rate fell by 0.5 percentage points or more), and stable economic periods as those with steady unemployment (years in which the national unemployment rate neither rose nor fell by more than 0.5 percentage points).

(This report is 7 pages long.)

Major Findings and Recommendations

The researchers identified the following findings and recommendations:

  1. Past research suggests that economic conditions can influence intervention effectiveness. Intervention effects might be stronger than usual during recessions if some workers cannot compete in the labor market during these difficult economic periods without the extra help interventions typically provide. Conversely, intervention effects might be weaker than usual during recessions if poor economic conditions limit opportunities for participants (For example, training programs cannot help people obtain jobs if none are available).
  2. Practitioners and policymakers should consider targeting resources towards interventions other than those focused on employment retention services during recoveries when the unemployment rate is falling. Interventions focused on education, training, work, and work-based learning show the most significant effects during recoveries compared with other types of interventions implemented during recoveries.
  3. Practitioners and policymakers should consider placing case management or other supports, and less emphasis on education and training, during recessions, when unemployment is increasing. Interventions focused on case management or other supports and employment services show the most significant effects during recessions compared with other types of interventions implemented during recessions.

Materials

Comments

Content Details

Methodology:

Topics:

Target Populations:

Programs:

Geographic Locations:

Industry Sectors:

  • Last Updated:
  • Created:
  • Resource Publication Date: 2021
  • Author(s): Dana, R.; Stanczyk, A.
  • Funding Source: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services
  • Resource Availability: Publicly available
  • Posted by: Justin Venneri
  • Posted in: Workforce System Strategies

Error

An error has occurred. The details of this error have been forwarded to our technical team. If you continue to experience issues, please contact our support team at support@workforcegps.org.

Event has ended