Skip to main content
Resource

State Strategies to Address the Needs of Justice-Involved Youth Impacted by Collateral Consequences

About

When young people engage with the juvenile justice system, they often encounter secondary repercussions. The National Governors Association (NGA) conducted a series of learning calls and hosted a virtual roundtable to discuss these repercussions. This report documents the insights and considerations of national, state, and local subject matter experts (SMEs) regarding strategies for mitigating the negative effects of collateral consequences.

During the fall of 2022, NGA convened a roundtable of SMEs to explore the impact of collateral consequences on justice-involved youth and their families and associated challenges for policymakers. The impact and duration of collateral consequences vary, including:

1. Immediate impacts: Consequences that occur simultaneously or shortly after the youth’s involvement with the juvenile justice system, including:

  • Financial penalties: Fines, fees, restitution, lost earnings, and other costs associated with attending juvenile court hearings or other proceedings,
  • Public benefits: Denial of government assistance as part of a needs-based program,
  • Driver’s license suspension: Suspension of a youth’s driver’s license by the state resulting from their sentence, and
  • Firearm possession restrictions: Restriction of a youth’s ability to possess a firearm resulting from their sentence.

2. Long-term impacts: Lasting or extensive effects on youth that linger well beyond the conclusion of their system involvement, including:

  • Economic mobility: Restriction of a youth’s ability to obtain employment, including job licensing, college enrollment, and/or entry into vocational training programs,
  • Record: A publicly available record that has compounding harmful effects on a youth’s access to housing, job prospects, and certain public benefits, and
  • Loss of support network: Erosion of support from a youth’s family and community upon reentry.

3. Compound impacts: Collateral consequences that have immediate and long-term impacts, including:

  • Housing: A youth’s difficulties finding or retaining housing after their involvement with the juvenile justice system,
  • Employment: Loss of employment while incarcerated, loss of employment opportunities upon reentry due to conditions set by parole or probation, difficulties acquiring licensure for certain careers, reduced job eligibility, and lowered earnings potential due to a youth’s involvement with the justice system,
  • Education: The loss of educational placements (e.g., suspension, expulsion, reassignment) due to laws requiring schools to be notified when a student enters the juvenile court system or difficulties enrolling in higher education or pursuing certain types of degrees due to a youth’s involvement with the justice system, and
  • Trauma and continued stigma: Negative psychological, social, or biological symptoms experienced anytime during or after a youth’s involvement with the juvenile justice system.

Major Findings and Recommendations

This report identifies several strategies to reduce collateral consequences for justice-involved youth. The major findings include:

1. Comprehensive reform measures:

  • Improving data systems: Enhanced data collection and reporting requirements using modern or upgraded technology can benefit youth by creating a more unified, coordinated service response within the juvenile justice system.
  • Raising the age: Collateral consequences can be reduced by providing a ceiling and floor age for being adjudicated in a juvenile court.
  • Diversion and deflection: Diversion programs prevent youth from acquiring a record by directing them toward a service-based response that prevents the youth from entering the adjudication process.
  • Reentry: Effective reentry plans are integral to the success of youth upon leaving the juvenile justice system. Reentry plans can include support from transitional facilities, reentry coordinators, and individual case managers equipped to help youth and their families obtain housing, food, mentoring, employment, and school enrollment.

2. Targeted policies:

  • Removing financial penalties: Reducing or eliminating fines or fees can reduce the impact of juvenile justice system involvement for youth from marginalized or low socioeconomic status households who are most at risk of harm.
  • Providing educational opportunities: Policies enhancing the availability of academic or vocational training can address the gap in educational opportunities for justice-involved youth.
  • Creating supports for older youth upon reentry: Ensuring support upon reentry helps address collateral consequences for older youth. Several program services or models can assist this population, including comprehensive discharge planning; prerelease programs; drug rehabilitation; and vocational training, work programs, housing, mentoring, and life-skills training.
  • Providing access to housing: Older youth can face a variety of challenges when attempting to obtain stable housing. Youth may experience discrimination from property owners and lack access to supportive housing services upon discharge.
  • Increasing awareness to record sealing, expungement, and vacatur: Allowing removal of adjudication from a record creates numerous benefits for youth, by means of expanded housing, employment, and educational opportunities.

Materials

Comments

Content Details

Methodology:

Topics:

Target Populations:

Programs:

Geographic Locations:

Industry Sectors:

  • Last Updated:
  • Created:
  • Resource Publication Date: 2023
  • Author(s): Moise, J.; Simonsen, E.; and Kearl, M.
  • Funding Source: Annie E. Casey Foundation
  • Resource Availability: Publicly available
  • Posted by: Justin Venneri
  • Posted in: Workforce System Strategies

Error

An error has occurred. The details of this error have been forwarded to our technical team. If you continue to experience issues, please contact our support team at support@workforcegps.org.

Event has ended