Skip to main content
Resource

AAI Expanding Registered Apprenticeship Opportunities to Underrepresented Populations

About

The American Apprenticeship Initiative (AAI) aimed to expand registered apprenticeship into industry sectors with few apprenticeships and to populations traditionally underrepresented in apprenticeship. This brief explores the characteristics, program experiences, and post-program outcomes of AAI apprentices from underrepresented populations, defined in this brief as women and people of color.

This brief examines the recruitment, program experiences, and post-program employment and earnings outcomes of AAI apprentices from underrepresented populations—defined as women and people of color (Black, Hispanic, and Other Races, specifically Asian, Native Hawaiian or Pacific Islander, Native American, or multiple races)—relative to all AAI apprentices and historically represented populations—defined as White men. This brief combines data from several sources, including U.S. Department of Labor program data, surveys of participants and grantees, and administrative earnings data. This unique combination of data provides an unprecedented opportunity to study the in-program experiences and outcomes of specific apprentices from underrepresented populations.

Several factors should be considered in interpreting the findings in this brief. First, the outcomes study measures participant-level outcomes, not AAI apprenticeship programs’ causal impact. That is, changes in employment and earnings cannot be attributed solely to the apprenticeship program. To do so would require a different study methodology. Second, the earnings analysis includes only apprentices whose programs ended by September 2019, so earnings are observed in the fifth post-program quarter. As such, it excludes longer-term programs in which apprentices were still enrolled. Thus, the earnings results largely reflect apprentices who completed short- and medium-term apprenticeship programs.

The brief examines four research questions:
1. What are the characteristics of AAI apprentices? How do they compare to all registered apprentices?
2. How did AAI apprentices, including those from underrepresented populations learn about apprenticeship? What were their motivations and concerns prior to starting the program?
3. What were AAI apprentices’ program experiences? How did the experiences of underrepresented populations compare to historically represented populations?
4. How do the post-program outcomes of AAI apprentices from underrepresented populations compare to those of historically represented populations?

(This report is 36 pages long.)

(The study took place from 2019-2022.)

Major Findings and Recommendations

The researchers identified the following findings:
• More than half of AAI apprentices were from underrepresented populations—that is, women and people of color.
• About three-quarters of AAI apprentices from underrepresented populations participated in nontraditional registered apprenticeship occupations—that is, occupations not affiliated with the construction industry.
• Most women, Black, Hispanic, and Other Race AAI apprentices completed their apprenticeship or were still enrolled in their program.
• After completing their registered apprenticeship, most women, Black, Hispanic, and Other Race apprentices remained with the employer who trained them.
• Women, Black, Hispanic, and Other Race apprentices experienced rapid earnings growth over the course of their apprenticeship.
• Most of the difference in earnings growth between Black and White apprentices occurs among women.

Please note, the outcomes study measures participant-level outcomes, not AAI apprenticeship programs’ causal impact. The study design does not allow for causal analysis of registered apprenticeship program. Based on the studies research methodology, the changes in employment and earnings cannot be solely attributed to the apprenticeship program, but the rapid increase in earnings for participants while in the program highlights the impact of expanding apprenticeship programs on minority and underrepresented populations.

The authors proposed the following recommendations:
• Registered apprenticeship programs might consider whether additional supportive services could help apprentices to persist and complete their programs—particularly for women, Black apprentices, and Hispanic apprentices, who were most likely to leave their programs due to personal or family problems.
• Although most apprentices remained with the same employer after program exit, programs might explore how to improve retention for Black apprentices, who were least likely to remain employed with the same employer.
• Future programs might consider ways to promote entry into and completion of apprenticeships in higher-growth occupations by underrepresented populations, and future research might explore underlying reasons for differences in occupations between groups.

Materials

Comments

Content Details

Methodology:

Topics:

Target Populations:

Programs:

Geographic Locations:

Industry Sectors:

  • Last Updated:
  • Created:
  • Resource Publication Date: 2022
  • Author(s): Walton, D.; Gardiner, K.
  • Funding Source: U.S. Department of Labor, Employment and Training Administration
  • Resource Availability: Publicly available
  • Posted by: Justin Venneri
  • Posted in: Workforce System Strategies

Error

An error has occurred. The details of this error have been forwarded to our technical team. If you continue to experience issues, please contact our support team at support@workforcegps.org.

Event has ended