Skip to main content
Resource

The Effect of Degree Attainment on Arrests: Evidence from a Randomized Social Experiment

About

Analyzes the effect of a high school degree or GED attainment on involvement with the criminal justice system using data from a random assignment study of the Job Corps program and explores whether the estimated effects vary by gender, race, and ethnicity.

“[The authors] examine the effect of educational attainment on criminal behavior using random assignment into Job Corps (JC) – the United States’ largest education and vocational training program for disadvantaged youth – as a source of exogenous variability in educational attainment” (p.1).

Specifically, the authors conduct an impact analysis by analyzing “the effect of earning a degree on the probability of being arrested employing data from the National Job Corps Study (NJCS). Job Corps is a comprehensive education and vocational training program that provides free services to economically disadvantaged youths (aged 16–24) in the U.S. Its goals are to educate, train, and prepare adolescents and young adults for employment in purposeful careers, allowing them to live independently. To achieve its goals, JC provides academic and vocational training leading to the attainment of degrees (high school or GED) or certificates in a myriad of trades. In addition, JC offers other services such as residential accommodation, social skills training, counseling, health services, and job placement. These services are delivered nationwide through 125 centers located across the U.S. and Puerto Rico that service roughly 60,000 new applicants each year” (p.4).

The authors make use of the “NJCS data set…[which is] representative of the population of eligible applicants to JC in 1994–1996 in the contiguous U.S. It consists of 7,953 youth (3,161 assigned to the control group and 4,792 to the treatment group), of which 4,724 are male, 3,229 female, 3,979 black, 2,036 white, and 1,404 Hispanic” (p.7-8). The authors analyze this preexisting data to answer their research questions, which include whether attainment of a high school diploma, GED, or vocational training lowers an individual’s likelihood of being arrested. They also compare their findings to the findings of previous studies that have exploited “changes in compulsory schooling laws as an instrumental variable in the estimation of the effect of education on arrest rates” (p.1).

The authors explain that the study touches on timely policy issues and may help answer whether “policies to promote education attainment could present an alternative” to “spending on police and law enforcement” (p.2).

(Abstractor: Author and Website Staff)

Major Findings and Recommendations

“[The authors’] main finding is that, despite the different assumptions, methods, and source of exogenous variation [they] exploit, [their] results are fairly consistent with the previous estimates of the causal effect of education on crime based on compulsory schooling laws. [The authors] interpret this as suggestive evidence that [their] estimated bounds and the results of those studies indeed capture a true causal effect of education on crime” (p.28-29). The authors provide the following findings about the effect of education on arrest rates: • Overall, “the attainment of a degree is estimated to reduce arrest rates by…about 32.6%” (p.1). • “[T]here is suggestive evidence that the attainment of a high school degree may have higher arrest-reducing effects, followed by vocational and GED degrees. Taking at face value the suggestive results on the arrest effects of the attainment of different degrees, along with the evidence on the larger financial returns of a high school degree relative to a GED degree,…a case could be made for modifying the Job Corps program to de-emphasize the attainment of GED in favor of high school degrees” (p.29). • “[The authors] also find suggestive evidence that the effects [of degree attainment on arrests] may be larger for males relative to females” (p.1). • The report also provides “separate analyses of the relationship between education and arrests for different demographic groups…[F]ew studies report effects for different demographic groups (especially by race/ethnicity), while the lifetime likelihood of imprisonment varies widely over these groups. For instance, as of 2009, the lifetime likelihood of imprisonment was 5.9, 32, and 17 percent for white, black, and Hispanic males, respectively” (p.3-4). The authors report that “[f]or black and white males, the lower bound shows that there is, respectively, at most, a 21.4 and 13.9 percentage-point reduction in the arrest rate due to the attainment of a degree….Lastly, while it is not possible to conclude from these results that the effect is larger for blacks than whites…the fact that the estimated lower bound is much larger (in absolute value) for blacks than for whites is consistent with [previous research findings] that the effect of schooling on crime reduction is larger for blacks” (p.25). (Abstractor: Author and Website Staff)

Materials

Comments

Content Details

Methodology:

Topics:

Target Populations:

Programs:

Geographic Locations:

Industry Sectors:

  • Last Updated:
  • Created:
  • Resource Publication Date: 2016
  • Author(s): Amin, Vikesh; Flores, Carlos A.; Flores-Lagunes, Alfonso; and Parisian, Daniel J.
  • Organizational Author(s): No organizational author identified
  • Funding Source: Funding source not identified
  • Resource Availability: Publicly available
  • Posted by: Long Dang
  • Posted in: Workforce System Strategies

Error

An error has occurred. The details of this error have been forwarded to our technical team. If you continue to experience issues, please contact our support team at support@workforcegps.org.

Event has ended