Skip to main content
Research/Evaluation Report

Implementation/Impact of a Goal Oriented Coaching Program for Michigan Cash Assistance Recipients

About

This report, a non-experimental impact analysis, describes the implementation and impact study findings from an evaluation of the relative effectiveness of two approaches to assist cash assistance applicants and recipients in finding and keeping jobs.

Conducted from 2016 to 2018 in two counties in Michigan, the study compares: (1) an enhancement to the state’s existing Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF) program that provides goal-oriented coaching to help applicants and recipients set and achieve employment-related goals (called the Michigan Goal Progress Success (MI-GPS) program), and (2) the state’s existing TANF program that primarily focuses on participation in required work activities, starting with a 21-day Application Eligibility Period (AEP) and followed by the “Partnership. Accountability. Training. Hope.” (PATH) program (the two-step program is called AEP/PATH). Using a rigorous research design, the study did not detect impacts on employment rates (the study’s confirmatory outcome), earnings, or cash assistance receipt over a three to five quarter follow-up period. While participation in employment services was high for both groups, compared to the AEP/PATH program, those assigned to the MI-GPS program received more one-on-one assistance with a number of goal-setting skills and their self-efficacy increased. However, there were no detectable effects on the other intermediate outcomes the MI-GPS was expected to impact.

Major Findings and Recommendations

The authors identified several findings and recommendations relating to outcomes for participants in the two approaches to assist cash assistance applicants and recipients in finding and keeping jobs.

Findings:

  • Michigan Goal Progress Success (MI-GPS) and (Application Eligibility Period/Partnership Accountability Training. Hope (AEP/PATH) operated largely as designed during the study period, differing as intended.
  • MI-GPS coaches consistently reported the goal-oriented coaching tools and the revised orientation developed for the MI-GPS program are valuable in implementing the approach.
  • MI-GPS coaches reported difficulties aligning the goal-oriented coaching with work participation rate requirements.

Findings related to impacts on service receipt and other intermediate outcomes:

  • No differences in participation in employment-focused activities, including job search assistance, were detected between the MI-GPS and the AEP/PATH groups.
  • Compared to the AEP/PATH program, the MI-GPS program increased the receipt of assistance on workplace behaviors and soft skills, which included goal-setting skills, provided through one-on-one meetings. MI-GPS increased self-efficacy, relative to the AEP/PATH program. However, the study does not detect an impact on other intermediate outcomes.

Findings related to impacts on employment, earnings and public assistance receipt:

  • There was no detectable impact on employment levels in the second quarter after random assignment for the MI-GPS program, compared to the AEP/PATH program. In addition, no differences in earnings were detected.
  • There was no detectable impact on MI-GPS on receipt of TANF benefits or TANF benefit amounts compared to AEP/PATH.
  • The MI-GPS reduced the amount of SNAP benefits received compared to the AEP/PATH program. However, the authors did not find an impact on the proportion receiving SNAP benefits.
  • There was no detectable difference between the MI-GPS and AEP/PATH groups in the characteristics of their current or most recent jobs, including wages and benefits.

Recommendations:

  • Different approaches can be used to achieve similar employment and public assistance outcomes for cash assistance recipients.
  • Additional ongoing studies that include refinements to the approach will provide critical information on the efficacy of goal-oriented coaching for improving employment and public assistance outcomes for cash assistance applicants.

Materials

Comments

Content Details

Methodology:

Topics:

Target Populations:

Programs:

Geographic Locations:

Industry Sectors:

  • Last Updated:
  • Created:
  • Resource Publication Date: 2020
  • Author(s): K. Martinson, K. Gardiner, E. Harvill, R. Cook
  • Funding Source: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Administration for Children and Families (ACF)
  • Resource Availability: Publicly available
  • Posted by: Placido Gomez
  • Posted in: Workforce System Strategies

Error

An error has occurred. The details of this error have been forwarded to our technical team. If you continue to experience issues, please contact our support team at support@workforcegps.org.

Event has ended