Skip to main content
Research/Evaluation Report

How Can Postsecondary Education and Training Programs Help Working Students Persist?

About

Millions of adults lack the postsecondary credentials needed to obtain many jobs in the current economy. Challenges to credential attainment include limited information about education and training options and their outcomes; expenses related to enrollment and persistence; and, for many students, the need to balance school with work responsibilities. This brief summarizes efforts to help students overcome challenges to enrolling and persisting in college and earning a credential.

This brief first summarizes the career pathways framework and associated evaluations. Then, using findings from these evaluations, it describes how programs that incorporate key features of the career pathways framework help their students persist and complete. Although not specific to working students, the strategies described below can help students balance school and work.

Career pathways are an integrative framework for promoting postsecondary education and training among nontraditional students. Participants enter the pathway at a step associated with their skill level. Following each step, they can continue their education or seek employment. Those who exit for work can return and enroll in the next step on the pathway. To effectively engage, retain, and facilitate learning of nontraditional students, the framework incorporates four components: academic and non-academic assessment, innovative basic and occupational skills training, academic and non-academic supports, and connections to employment.

To build the body of knowledge about the design, implementation, and impacts on education, employment, and earnings of programs aligned with the career pathways framework, particularly those that target low-income nontraditional students, the researchers utilized data from evaluations of career pathways interventions, including the Pathways for Advancing Careers and Education (PACE) Project, and evaluations of two rounds of the Health Profession Opportunity Grants Program (HPOG 1.0 and HPOG 2.0).

This brief uses data from the PACE and HPOG 1.0 implementation studies and in-depth interviews with a sample of 153 HPOG 2.0 study participants. Most applicants to programs in these studies were nontraditional students.—e.g., age 25 or older, parents, low-income, and working. The PACE and HPOG 1.0 implementation studies documented components of the programs included in the studies, while HPOG 2.0 study participants described in their own words their reasons for working while in school and the programmatic components that help them persevere.

The PACE project is a multi-site, random assignment evaluation of promising strategies for increasing employment and self-sufficiency among low-income families.

HPOG provides education and training to TANF recipients and other low-income individuals for occupations in the health care field that pay well and are expected to either experience labor shortages or be in high demand.

(This report is 9 pages long.)

Major Findings and Recommendations

The researchers identified the following selected findings:

1. Work schedules can reduce enrollment and persistence in school; shortening the length of the program and providing flexibility in course offerings can help.

  • Training providers addressed scheduling conflicts by accelerating courses to compress content into a shorter time.
  • Some programs offered flexible delivery strategies, such as evening scheduling, self-paced instruction, convenient training locations, and technology-supported distance learning.

2. Participant challenges can affect persistence in school; program advisors can link students to an array of supports.

  • Programs in the HPOG 1.0 and PACE studies offered a range of supports, such as transportation, childcare, and referrals to other services, as well as helping participants plan their academic schedules around their work needs. Most often, advisors (also referred to as coordinators, counselors, and advisors) coordinate supports.

3. Even when students are working, their earnings might not cover costs associated with school, unexpected emergencies, and day-to-day living, with implications for persistence; programs can offer a range of financial supports.

  • Programs in the HPOG and PACE studies offered participants varying levels of financial support. All programs provided some assistance with school-related costs, such as direct support for tuition or assistance filling out financial aid forms. Some PACE programs also provided stipends and funds to address emergencies.

4. Some participants might need to begin working after enrolling in school; programs can help connect students to jobs.

  • HPOG programs helped participants find jobs while they were still active in the program. Some were related to healthcare and provided an opportunity for gaining relevant experience and additional skill-building. In other cases, the jobs may have generated income, providing participants with the resources to continue training and general work experience.
  • Some PACE programs had staff to help enrolled participants find paid work.

The researchers also identified the following recommendations for future consideration:

  1. Systematically explore if and how programs assess participant employment status at intake and the need for supports.
  2. Prevalence of supports to help participants combine work and school, and the effectiveness of supports from the perspectives of students and program staff.

Materials

Comments

Content Details

Methodology:

Topics:

Target Populations:

Programs:

Geographic Locations:

Industry Sectors:

  • Last Updated:
  • Created:
  • Resource Publication Date: 2021
  • Author(s): Gardiner, K.
  • Funding Source: Administration for Children and Families (ACF), U.S. Department of Health and Human Services
  • Resource Availability: Publicly available
  • Posted by: Justin Venneri
  • Posted in: Workforce System Strategies

Error

An error has occurred. The details of this error have been forwarded to our technical team. If you continue to experience issues, please contact our support team at support@workforcegps.org.

Event has ended