Instituto del Progreso Latinos Carreras en Salud Program Six-Year Impact Report
About
Carreras aims to provide training to Latinos with low income with a seven-course pathway that starts with Career English as a Second Language (ESL) and concludes with Licensed Practical Nurse (LPN). It incorporates a range of academic and non-academic services and supports to help participants complete their first course and advance to subsequent ones. This research evaluated whether Carreras successfully provided training to the target population and whether the program’s efforts led to impacts on credentials, earnings, healthcare employment, and other life outcomes.
Carreras en Salud consists of five elements:
- a structured healthcare training pathway, starting at low skills levels;
- contextualized and accelerated basic skills and ESL instruction;
- academic advising and non-academic supports;
- financial assistance; and
- employment services.
The evaluation of Carreras en Salud used a rigorous experimental design. This report describes Carreras’s long-term, six-year impacts on educational attainment, earnings and employment, and other life outcomes. It extends the analyses of program effects measured 18 months and three years after randomization.
Six years after random assignment, what were the effects of Carreras en Salud on the following outcomes? The evaluation focused on the following questions:
- receipt of long-term college credentials, particularly the Licensed Practical Nurse (LPN) credential;
- earnings;
- employment, job quality, and career progress; and
- family economic well-being and child outcomes.
(This report is 57 pages long.)
Major Findings and Recommendations
The researchers identified the following findings:
- Increased by 4 percent points receipt of college credentials requiring at least one year of full-time college, the confirmatory outcome in the education domain for the six-year impact study.
- 17 percent of the treatment group received such a credential, compared to 13 percent of the control group. LPN is the Carreras course of study that fits this category.
- Had no detectable impact on average quarterly earnings in follow-up quarters 23 and 24, the confirmatory outcome in the earnings and employment domain for the six-year impact study. The average quarterly earnings for treatment group members were $6,343, compared to $6,053 for the control group.
- Had a 6 percent impact on the percent receiving quarterly earnings averaging $6,825 or more across quarters 23 and 24. 49 percent of the treatment group earned this threshold compared to 43 percent of the control group. Further analysis found that the impact had a 6 percent impact on employment in the healthcare field.
- Had a 6 percent impact on employment in the healthcare field. 32 percent of treatment group members reported working in the healthcare field at the time of the follow-up survey, compared to 26 percent of control group members. However, the program had no detectable impact on other employment outcomes or career progress measures, including the proportion working full-time, the percentage working in a job that offered five types of benefits, or self-reported access to a career network.
- Had no detectable impact on measures of financial well-being. The evaluation found no impact on the ability to handle an emergency of $400 or more or financial distress. Nor did Carreras have a detectable impact on receipt of means-tested public benefits.
The researchers provided the following recommendations:
- Explore adding more in-program and post-programming advising. All Carreras participants receive academic advising, but non-academic Upper bridge participants might benefit from assistance with non-academic issues that could affect persistence, such as childcare and guidance on balancing work and school.
- Consider full-time enrollment for Pre-LPN and subsequent steps. Full-time attendance shortens the timeline for earning a credential and is associated with lower drop-out rates relative to part-time status.
- Explore offering a wider range of healthcare occupational training, including occupations outside direct patient care.
Materials
Comments
Content Details
Methodology:
Topics:
Target Populations:
Programs:
Geographic Locations:
Industry Sectors:
- Last Updated:
- Created:
- Resource Publication Date: 2022
- Author(s): Gardiner, K.; Grittner, A.
- Funding Source: Administration for Children and Families (ACF), U.S. Department of Health and Human Services
- Resource Availability: Publicly available
- Posted by: Justin Venneri
- Posted in: Workforce System Strategies