Skip to main content
Resource

The Pathways Clearinghouse Guide for Researchers

About

This guide introduces researchers to the Pathways Clearinghouse by providing a high-level overview of its processes for selecting studies for review, assigning study quality ratings, and assessing the evidence of effectiveness of an intervention. It then describes the Pathways Clearinghouse review standards and the reasoning behind them and outlines common pitfalls that might cause studies to receive lower quality ratings.

The Pathways Clearinghouse assesses existing research through a screening and review process. The team first screens existing research for eligibility. Then, reviewers evaluate the strength of the study’s evidence and assign a study rating. Finally, the Pathways Clearinghouse groups studies into interventions and assigns effectiveness ratings to interventions based on the available evidence. This guide describes each step in detail.

Researchers and research funders can use this high-level overview to understand better the Pathways Clearinghouse and its processes for selecting studies for review, assigning study quality ratings, and assessing the evidence of effectiveness of an intervention. In particular, researchers can use this guide to understand:

  • How to conduct studies that may be eligible to receive the highest possible quality ratings from the Pathways Clearinghouse.
  • Why their study was or was not included in the Pathways Clearinghouse, why their study received its study quality rating, and how their study was grouped with other studies to assess intervention effectiveness.
  • Common pitfalls for study authors to avoid to ensure their research achieves a high-quality rating and therefore reaches the broadest possible audience through Pathways Clearinghouse dissemination efforts.

(This report is 19 pages long.)

Major Findings and Recommendations

Recommendations of what Pathways Clearinghouse looks for in a study:

Study Characteristics:

  • What services are offered to the intervention group? To the comparison group?
  • Where did the intervention take place?
  • What are the characteristics of the study participants?
  • How was the intervention implemented (such as dosage, costs of implementation, and any deviations between actual and intended implementation)?
    What was the implementing organization, and who funded the program and study?

Study Design and Analysis:

  • How were the intervention and comparison groups formed? What is the unit of assignment?
  • If the study team attempted to collect outcome data for only a subset of the people in the intervention and comparison groups, how was this subset selected?
  • What outcome measures were used to assess the impacts of the intervention? When were these outcomes measured?
  • How did the analysis account for missing data?

Study Data:

  • What are the sample sizes, unadjusted means, and standard deviations for each key characteristic (reported in Exhibit 10) of the intervention and comparison groups at baseline?
  • What are the sample sizes of the intervention and comparison group for each analysis performed in the study?
  • What are the estimated findings (including standard deviations, standard errors, or p-values) for each outcome measure in the analysis?

Materials

Comments

Content Details

Methodology:

Topics:

Target Populations:

Programs:

Geographic Locations:

Industry Sectors:

  • Last Updated:
  • Created:
  • Resource Publication Date: 2022
  • Author(s): Shiferaw, L.; McCallum, D; Rotz, D.
  • Resource Availability: Publicly available
  • Posted by: Wesley Peterson
  • Posted in: Workforce System Strategies

Error

An error has occurred. The details of this error have been forwarded to our technical team. If you continue to experience issues, please contact our support team at support@workforcegps.org.

Event has ended